Neurological Disorders
Question #8178
25 days ago
31

Babinski Sign - #8178

Anonymously

I recently came across the term Babinski sign while researching neurological reflexes, and I want to understand what it indicates. I know it involves a reflex test where the doctor strokes the bottom of the foot to see how the toes respond, but what does a positive or negative Babinski sign actually mean? From what I’ve read, a positive Babinski sign in infants is considered normal, but in adults, it can be a sign of neurological problems. Why is it normal in babies but abnormal in older children and adults? At what age does this reflex typically disappear? One thing I’m really curious about is what conditions a positive Babinski sign can indicate. I read that it’s often linked to brain or spinal cord injuries, multiple sclerosis, and other neurological disorders. How reliable is this test in diagnosing these conditions? Can a positive Babinski sign be temporary, or does it always mean there’s serious nerve damage? I also want to know whether the Babinski sign can be falsely positive due to things like stress, muscle fatigue, or medication side effects. If someone has a positive response but no other neurological symptoms, should they still be concerned? Another thing I’m wondering about is how doctors interpret the Babinski sign along with other neurological tests. Are there other reflex tests that help confirm whether a neurological disorder is present? What are the next steps if a patient has an abnormal Babinski sign? If anyone has experience with the Babinski sign, whether through personal diagnosis or as a medical professional, I’d love to hear more about its significance. How often does it actually indicate a serious condition, and what other symptoms usually appear alongside it?

Babinski sign
Neurological reflex
Brain and spinal cord injury
Neurological disorders
Multiple sclerosis
Reflex testing
Nervous system health
Question is closed

On the Ask Doctors service, online consultations with doctors for Neurological Disorders are available for any issue that concerns you. Expert doctors provide consultations around the clock and for free. Ask your question and get an answer right away!

Doctors’ responses

Dr. Evgeny Arsentev
I am a highly qualified medical professional with over 15 years of experience in General Medicine. My expertise spans diagnosing and treating a wide range of conditions, providing evidence-based care, and mentoring junior doctors. I am dedicated to ensuring patient well-being through a combination of clinical skills and compassionate care.
24 days ago
The Babinski sign is indeed an important neurological reflex evaluated by stroking the sole of the foot and observing the response of the toes. In a healthy adult, the normal response is to curl the toes downward (negative Babinski sign), while a positive Babinski sign, where the big toe extends upward and the other toes fan out, can suggest certain neurological conditions. You're correct that a positive Babinski sign is normal in infants up to about 2 years of age because their central nervous system (CNS) is still developing. During this period, the brain is not fully mature, which allows the positive response. As the child develops, typically by around 6 months to 2 years, this reflex should integrate into more mature patterns of movement, becoming negative as the nervous system matures. In adults, a positive Babinski sign indicates that there may be an issue with the CNS, particularly the pathways in the brain or spinal cord. A positive Babinski sign can potentially indicate several conditions, including brain or spinal cord injuries, multiple sclerosis, amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), and tumors or infections affecting the CNS. The reliability of the Babinski sign lies in its utility as part of a broader neurological assessment; while it can suggest neurological compromise, it is not solely diagnostic. The presence of other neurological symptoms, such as weakness, sensory loss, or coordination issues, would strengthen the case for an underlying condition. It is also worth noting that conditions could account for a positive response temporarily. Factors like stress, muscle fatigue, or certain medications may temporarily influence reflex responses, although they should typically be evaluated in conjunction with other neurological assessments. If someone experiences a positive Babinski sign but lacks other concerning neurological symptoms, it would still warrant further evaluation to rule out any neurological conditions, though it isn't inherently alarming. Other reflex tests that doctors may utilize alongside the Babinski sign include the knee jerk (patellar reflex), ankle jerk (Achilles reflex), and various tests of coordination and sensation. Together, these tests allow for a more comprehensive assessment of the neurological system. If an abnormal Babinski sign is noted, the next steps typically involve a thorough neurological examination to assess for additional symptoms, imaging studies like an MRI or CT scan if indicated, and possibly laboratory tests to identify specific conditions. This integrated approach helps provide a clearer picture and establish if neurological disorders are present or if alternative explanations exist. In summary, while a positive Babinski sign can signal possible neurological issues, its presence must be interpreted alongside other clinical signs and symptoms. It’s always advisable for individuals with these concerns to consult a healthcare professional for a detailed examination and potential follow-up investigations.
Accepted response

0 replies

If you need a detailed answer, ask your question to a doctor

A doctor will answer all of your questions, advise you what to do now to get better, what to do in the future, what best treatments and practices should be followed.

About our doctors

Only qualified doctors who have confirmed the availability of medical education and other certificates of medical practice consult on our service.


Related questions